Category: Academic & Scholarly News

  • Help Me Decide — Is a “Replacement” New Collateral

    Posted by

    This semester, I have been teaching secured credit from Lynn LoPucki and Elizabeth Warren's wonderful textbook. One of the problems from the book was, I believe, inspired by my former colleague at UNLV and current bankruptcy judge, Bruce Markell, who requires his students to draft a security agreement taking a security interest in an object he brought to class. A student's agreement has presented an interpretive issue with the problem, and I told him I would get the input of our readership on Credit Slips. One thing the assignment allowed me to do is to talk about boilerplate. There is nothing necessarily wrong with boilerplate, but we should understand what it is doing when we use it.

    The object I brought to class was a baseball signed by the great Lou Brock, a Hall of Fame outfielder for the St. Louis Cardinals. The instructions specifically state that the students are to draft a security agreement taking a security interest in this object–the baseball–and nothing else. If the students comply with the instructions, they get a pass on the assignment, and if not, they get a fail. As Markell always said to me–in the real world there is no such thing as a security agreement that is almost valid.

    (more…)

  • A Failure of Research: Posner on Law Professors and the Financial Crisis

    Posted by

    I just came across a Richard Posner piece in the Atlantic that claims that law professors "have not made a contribution to the understanding and resolution of the current economic crisis, even thought it bristles with legal questions."   

    Whoa!  This statement is really insulting to the large cadre of legal scholars (including many Slipsters) who have been focusing their energies on financial regulation and the crisis for far longer than Judge Posner, whose arrival to the debate is welcome, if recent.

    Whatever one thinks of the quality of the work of law professors on financial regulation and the crisis, its existence cannot be denied, as Kenneth Anderson notes on Volokh Conspiracy.  Off the top of my head, I can count at least three dozen law professors who are active in this area, and can think of at least half-dozen symposia that have already occurred and a few crisis-themed law review volumes.  We have been writing articles and policy papers, speaking at legal and non-legal conferences, testifying for years on Capitol Hill, drafting legislation (if only the good judge knew just how many pieces of legislation had drafting input from authors of this blog alone…), and actively serving in government:  Daniel Tarullo as Fed governor, Michael Barr as Assistant Treasury Secretary for Financial Institutions, Peter Swire with the NEC, Cass Sunstein at OIRA, and Elizabeth Warren as Congressional Oversight Panel Chair.  Posner might not be bothered to read our work, but we exist.

    [9.4.09–comments are now open]

    (more…)

  • Fed Conference on Consumer Credit

    Posted by

    The Federal Reserve Bank of Philadelphia is hosting its biennial researh conference, Recent Developments in Consumer Credit and Payments. The seven selected papers represent hot topics in economic research on consumer credit. Two papers focus on mortgage issues, including a paper by Tomasz Piskorski on the effects of securitization on distressed loan renegotiation. This has been a hotly contested topic, both on Credit Slips and in policy circles. The New York Times had a front-page story today on the incentives of servicers to modify loans, touching upon studies that examine how and whether securitization may limit modifications. Other papers deal with payday borrowing, bankruptcy reform, and retail lending. The full agenda is here.

    The conference will be held Sept. 24-25 in Philadelphia. Registration information is available from the first link above.

  • The Tabb-ed Second Edition Is Out

    Posted by

    From time to time, I'm asked to recommend a desk reference on bankruptcy law. I have long thought that it was hard to top Charles Tabb's The Law of Bankruptcy. Of late, my only hesitation was that I had thought that for too long. The first edition was more than ten years old. Still, it was a concise and well-written text that covered many timeless principles of bankruptcy law, and despite the passage of time, I still found occasion to use it .

    As I was walking through our dean's suite today, it was fantastic to see a gleaming copy of the faculty's newest book proudly on display. The second edition of this wonderful treatise has just become available. The book is organized in a way that will make bankruptcy law accessible to novices. The first edition began each topic with first principles, and Tabb writes in a clear manner that makes any topic understandable. At 1,447 pages, the book also is no quick overview of bankruptcy law. I often used the first edition as a starting point on research topics.

    Congratulations to Charles Tabb–my good friend, colleague, and teacher–on the arrival of this new edition. It is sure to become one of the bellwether works in the field.

  • Open-Source Law Review Publication Contracts

    Posted by

    I know this isn't standard Credit Slips fare and will probably be of little interest to most readers, but it's of reasonable concern to academic readers:  the lack of standardization among law review publication contracts. 

    (more…)

  • ABA Consumer Protection Conference: Credit Slips out in Force

    Posted by

    Angie Littwin and I will be speaking on a very timely panel about the need for a consumer financial product safety commission Consumer Financial Protection Agency (CoFiPro=Coffee Pro?) at the ABA’s Section on Antitrust ‘s Consumer Protection Conference at Georgetown.

    The conference features appearances by numerous current and former FTC and state officials–including a greeting by the incoming head of the Consumer Protection bureau, my GULC colleague David Vladeck–as well as prominent private practitioners. Sessions cover issues including internet issues (with special attention to the perhaps surprising scope of Section 230 of the CDA), privacy, the use of empirical evidence, and the different standards applied by different regulators, including the FTC, NAD, and courts applying the Lanham Act.

    Just to play with acronyms for proposed Consumer Financial Protection Agency: CoFiPro=Coffee Pro? or CoFinPro=Coffin Pro?

  • Mortgage Symposium at Pepperdine

    Posted by

    On Friday, Pepperdine University School of Law is hosting a symposium entitled, "Bringing Down the Curtain on the Current Mortgage Crisis and Preventing a Return Engagement." As the announcement notes, the Pepperdine Law Review is bringing top scholars and Bob Lawless to campus. OK, it doesn't actually say that explicitly, but I've always wanted such an announcement to say something like that. Besides myself, the speakers include Ann Burkhart, Rick Caruso, Deborah Dakin, Wilson Freyermuth, Sam Gerdano, Melissa Jacoby, Alex M. Johnson, Jr., Timothy Mayopoulos, Grant Nelson, Mark Scarberry, and Dale Whitman. Truly trivial question: which four were once colleagues at the University of Missouri School of Law?

    The papers will be published in the Pepperdine Law Review. My contribution has been co-authored by my research assistant extraordinaire, Jeff Paulsen. Before he goes off for a two-year clerkship with Judge Jack Schmetterer in the bankruptcy court in Chicago, I wanted to take advantage of his talent work with Jeff on a scholarly piece. We have a working title of "The Missing History of Bankruptcy Mortgage Modification." The short version is that the current rule against modifying mortgages in bankruptcy is not the considered policy choice as it is often portrayed. Rather, like many things, the history is much messier, and path dependence explains a lot of it. When we have a version for SSRN, I'll post a more detailed summary.

  • AALS Debtor-Creditor Call for Papers

    Posted by

    The Association of American Law Schools’ Debtor-Creditor Section issued a call for papers on debtor-creditor scholarship, most broadly understood, for presentation at the AALS Annual Meeting in New Orleans in January 2010. Proposals are welcome from a wide array of perspectives and strong preference will be given to proposals from those who will not yet have been awarded tenure by January 2010 and to those whose work is not already well known within the section. Proposals may be in any stage of production, from early-stage idea to mid-stage working draft to polished paper, though work that will not be published by January 2010 will be strongly preferred.  There is no publication commitment. Deadline for submission is Monday, August 31, 2009. Please email proposals to Jason Kilborn at jkilborn@jmls.edu.

    Download AALS_section_Call_for_Papers_2009

  • Rewriting Frankenstein Contracts

    Posted by

    A bit of shameless self-promotion:  former Credit Slips guest blogger Anna Gelpern and I have a new paper, "Rewriting Frankenstein Contracts:  Workout Prohibitions in Residential Mortgage-Backed Securities" posted to SSRN.  Increasing attention has been paid to the problems securitization contracts (pooling and servicing agreements) pose to modification of troubled mortgages.  Our paper situates RMBS contracts in the contract theory literature and argues for eliminating workout prohibitions through targeted legislation and administrative mandates.  En route to this conclusion, we try to construct a typology of contract rigidities (formal-structural-functional), and review New Deal jurisprudence on rewriting payment-in-gold clauses in contracts, breaking up utility holding companies, and stopping farm foreclosures. The abstract is below the break.  


    (more…)

  • Mortgage Database

    Posted by

    The National Mortgage Data Repository is making its data available to a select group of applicants to conduct mortgage resarch. The Repository is a joint project of the National Consumer Law Center and the University of Connecticut School of Lawand includes data from 750 loans made in 10-15 states between 1994 and 2007. While the database isn't as comprehensive as HMDA or Loan Performance, it has a unique collection of data and the data are free. For each loan, the researchers have gathered the loan application, the truth in lending disclosure, the good faith estimate, the HUD-1 Settlement Statement, and the loan note. These are the core documents in a mortgage origination, making this a great dataset to study the costs of mortgage credit and underwriting decisions.

    Research proposals of 2 single-spaced pages are due by March 31, 2009. Submissions are welcome not only from academics but also from advocates, attorneys, and other professionals interested in mortgage issues. (Having teamed up with guest blogger Tara Twomey for our Mortgage Studyof bankruptcy and homeownership, I encourage my scholarly colleagues to consider the many virtues of collaborating on research with attorney/practitioners). Authors whose projects are selected will present their work at a symposium in Spring 2010 at Valparaiso University School of Law. The full call for papers is here: Download Investigating Lender Practices in the Subprime Mortgage Market . Thanks to former guest blogger Pat McCoy for sharing this opportunity with Credit Slips.