Category: Consumer Financial Protection Bureau

  • The Anti-Consumer Agenda

    Posted by

    I often find myself annoyed by left-wing (and occassionally right-wing) anti-business screeds that decry corporations, big business, etc.  I don't find anything inherently troubling about corporate form or business size, and I have no problem with profit-motivated actors (individual or corporate), so long as they play fair. Mindless attacks on the business community have the unfortunate effect of undermining perceived validity of more targeted, thoughtful concerns through a guilt-by-association phenomenon. 

    But business and consumer interests often diverge. Now, it should hardly be controversial that there is an unequal playing field between businesses and consumers. Generally, businesses know more about their products than consumers and have more bargaining power than consumers. (Yes, there are information assymetries running the opposite way, which is a particularly salient problem for credit and insurance products.) For many businesses, it is important to maintain this assymetry of information and bargaining power, as there's profit in it.

    In theory, and I emphasize in theory, competition should eliminate many of the problems these assymetries create for consumers, but there's no such thing as a perfect, complete market, just varying degrees of market imperfection, so competition alone cannot be relied upon to solve everything. What, if anything else, should be done is an open question, but when one looks at a range of seemingly unconnected recent public policy issues, a troubling common theme emerges.

    Instead of a laboratory of experiements to help level the b2c playing field, we see a different trend emerging:  a distinct anti-consumer agenda that aims to reduce consumer bargaining power and information.  Consider the common theme that runs through the following issues: 

    • AT&T v. Concepcion (waiver of class actions in arbitrations)
    • Attempts to bust up public employee unions (and attacks on unions in general, such as the failure of Card Check legislation)
    • Citizens United (corporate speech rights)
    • Attempts to retain the current corrupt swipe fee system (failure of antitrust)
    • Attacks on public health insurance (prohibition on Medicare bargaining over prescription drug prices and the death of the public option)
    • Attempts to first kill off and now to maim the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau

    (more…)

  • American Bankers Association Now Backs Warren

    Posted by

    A few years back there was a person who used to write for Credit Slips named Elizabeth Warren. She left the blog, and we had heard she took a government job in Washington, DC. Now, word comes via our friends at the CL&P Blog that the American Bankers Association is backing her candidacy to head the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau.

    This is great news, and I hope it breaks the political logjam against her nomination. President Obama could not pick a better person to head the CFPB.

    UPDATE (5/3): As noted by commenter JJM, the president of the American Bankers Association is now backtracking on his statement. See here from Jeff Gelles at the Philadelphia Inquirer (which includes a wonderful analysis of a heretofore unknown phenomenon to me: the Kinsley gaffe).

  • The Elizabeth Warren Witch Hunt Continues

    Posted by

    The latest chapter in the Republicans' Elizabeth Warren witchhunt would be farcical, if it didn't have such potentially serious consequences. Congressional Republicans are now demanding that Elizabeth Warren recant her Congressional testimony about her role in the non-existent mortgage servicing settlement.  The problem?  Professor Warren stated that she "advised" the Treasury Secretary on the settlement, whereas Republicans allege that:

    according to the CFPB Settlement Presentation, the CFPB did more than provide advice:  it recommended the goals and provided a detailed framework for the structure of the settlement….rather than merely dispensing advice to those involved in negotiating the settlement, the CFPB was actually its primary architect.

    In other words, the Republicans are insinuating that Professor Warren misled Congress in her testimony because she said she "advised" when in fact she "recommended." This charge is truly laughable and shows what a desperate witchhunt the Congressional Republicans are conducting as part of their rear-guard action for the banks. This doesn't even pass the straight face test. I half expect their next letter to demand that Elizabeth Warren show up at the House dunking pond to see if she floats or sinks.

    (more…)

  • The Wall Street Journal’s CFPB Smear Campaign Continues

    Posted by

    The Wall Street Journal editorial page has its fourth hit job in two weeks attacking Elizabeth Warren. It's hard to think of the last time the WSJ editorial page assaulted any individual government official for such extended and personalized animus. (Maybe President Clinton or Elliot Spitzer?) And as I've noted before (here and here), the WSJ keeps stretching the facts in these percussive pieces.

    The WSJ's attacks are also way out of line with the mainstream media. You might say they're tone-deaf. Here's a litany of recent pieces supporting the CFPB: SFChronicle, Californian, Las Vegas Sun, Philadelphia Inquirer (and again here), Bangor Daily News, Miami Herald. It would seem that everyone except Wall Street understands the need for the CFPB and that Elizabeth Warren is the person for the directorship. 

    The WSJ raises three criticisms of Warren and the CFPB: (1) lack of accountability on rulemaking, (2) lack of control over funding, and (3) disingenuousness about the CFPB's role in servicing fraud settlement negotiations. The WSJ's real issue, however, isn't the level of the CFPB's accountability or funding or even its role in the servicing settlement. It's the CFPB's very existence.

    Congress ought to put Ms. Warren's unaccountable bureau under Treasury with an annual budget—or, better, put it entirely out of business.

    Complaints about accountability or funding are just cover for the banks' WSJ's real agenda–letting the banks go back to business as usual. How well did that work out for the country in 2008? Heckuva job, Brownie!

    The WSJ editorial page has never managed to articulate an argument for why there should not be a CFPB, however. I think there's a reason for that–there isn't one that can be made with a straight face. The WSJ's motivation is it is afraid that the CFPB will result in greater fairness, transparency, and efficiency in consumer finance markets–and hence less profit for Wall Street. But even the WSJ knows that's not an argument it can make in public. So instead, the WSJ editorial page harps on accountability and legality. Let's see how well these strawmen stand up to the fire of reason.

    (more…)

  • A Bisl Kissel or Why the Kissel Kerfuffle Misses the Point

    Posted by

    The gloves have really come off between the Wall Street Journal Editorial Page and the CFPB and its defenders. Zach Carter blogged on HuffPo about how the WSJ's attacks on Elizabeth Warren and the CFPB were authored by Mary Kissel, who worked for a few years at Goldman Sachs before joining the WSJ. The implication here was that Kissel is carrying water for Goldman's regulatory agenda because of her past association. (Full disclosure: I was vaguely acquainted with Kissel in college, but the only thing I recall about her was that she played the marimba quite well.) The WSJ spluttered back at this "ad hominem attack," calling it a smear job because it was anonymously sourced. 

    Clearly this struck a nerve with the WSJ; I guess their editorial writers aren't used to being called to account. Ultimately, Kissel and her background are at best irrelevant to the story.  It doesn't really matter what motivates Kissel; the WSJ would have found another soldier to carry out the hit. At worst, though the Kissel Kerfuffle is a distraction from the real issue–that the WSJ's editorial page coverage of Elizabeth Warren and the CFPB have been substantively misleading. 

    (more…)

  • Shakedown or Bailout? The Mortgage Servicing Settlement

    Posted by

    How's this for contrasting interpretations:  the AGs' proposed mortgage servicing settlement is being termed both a "shakedown" (WSJ editorial page) and a "bailout." (Jesse Eisinger at ProPublica–ok, he uses the word "gift", but still).  

    Wow.  That's some divergence in characterization of an incomplete term sheet.

    I think both of these interpretations miss the mark, as neither really gets what a settlement is.  A settlement is a voluntary contract and represents compromises by both sides in order to avoid uncertain litigation outcome.  The WSJ's interpretation is just nuts–the cheerleaders for freedom of contract are complaining about the price of a contract offer.  Addressing Eisinger's bailout charge is more complex.  Details below the break.    

    (more…)

  • Foreclosure Fraud Settlement: The Empire Strikes Back (or Why Are Republicans So Obsessed with Backdoor Cramdown?)

    Posted by

    It's not surprising to see the banks and their supporters on the Hill pushing back on the proposed Foreclosure Fraud settlement term sheet. (See here and here and here).  There seem to be three major lines coming out of the banks:

     (1) It's "backdoor cramdown," and the agencies shouldn't be pursuing a policy rejected by Congress.  

    Thus, House Republicans wrote to Treasury Secretary Geithner that "The settlement agreement not only legislates new standards and practices for the servicing industry, it also resuscitates programs and policies [namely bankruptcy cramdown] that have not worked or that Congress has explicitly rejected."  These House Republicans want to know:  "What specific legal authority grants federal and state regulators and agencies the power to require mortgage principal reductions when the House and Senate have voted down such proposals?"  .  Similarly a coterie of bank-friendly pundits chimed in calling this sub rosa cramdown.  

    (2) CFPB has no business being involved given that it doesn't have a director.  

    This has to be read between the lines as a thinly veiled Elizabeth Warren witch hunt.  At least one commentator was upfront about that in the American Banker.   

    (3) The settlement could negatively affect the safety and soundness of the banks.  

    Let me address all of these points.  There's a lot of willful confusion about this term sheet and what it is.  

    (more…)

  • BoA Nonesense

    Posted by

    The irony of the CEO of Bank of America kvetching that it would be unfair to responsible homeowners for the bank to give principal reductions to homeowners in default is really too much. Does he recall that he's the CEO of a bank that is only still in business by grace of a federal bailout?

    But where is Moynihan getting that he'll be required to help only deadbeats, when he feels morally bound to share the love with current borrowers?  I sure didn't see anything in the AG/CFPB term sheet that requires that.  Instead, it leaves the question of who will live and who will die up to the banks, precisely so they can't bellyache that federal regulation is restricting their ability to do loan mods, as they have about HAMP.  

    Here's the relevant language from the term sheet.  As far as I can see, the basic principle for mods is NPV maximization (i.e., investor protection).  Default status surely plays a role in that calculus, but it's the servicer's decision how to account for that: 

    • "Servicers employees shall not advise, instruct, or recommend that borrowers go into default in order to qualify for loss mitigation relief."  (p. 17)
    • "Servicer shall consider and apply principal reductions in appropriate circumstances for sustainable modifications." (p. 18) 
    • There is a particular requirement that servicers evaluate all defaulted loans with an LTV>100% or CLTV>115% for principal mods in a particular manner, but that's not saying only defaulted loans are eligible for principal mods. (p. 18)

    My read here is that Moynihan's real complaint is that BoA might have to dish out $4-5B (relative to earnings of $35-40B, it's not so huge, even if it is is the largest bank fine ever by an order of magnitude) and leave the AGs and CFPB with the ability to hammer it for noncompliance.  (And again, I emphasize that the AGs and CFPB do not currently have authority over things like noncompliance with HAMP or PSAs, but would under the term sheet, meaning there would be a real cop on the beat).  

  • Foreclosure-Gate Settlement–More Thoughts

    Posted by

    [Updated 3.8.11]

    Some bloggers on the left (e.g. here) and on the fringe right (see here)  are upset with the servicing standard term sheet that got leaked because they think it just prohibits things that are already illegal.  This is an incorrect reading of the term sheet.  Let me give three examples.

    (more…)