Category: Uncategorized

  • What’s the Democrats’ Legislative Agenda in Financial Regulation and Consumer Protection?

    Posted by

    The extent of the Blue wave last night caught a lot of the Democratic policy establishment unprepared. Democrats are suddenly going to be able to move legislation, but not override vetos. I don’t sense, however, that there’s a clear Democratic legislative agenda, at least in financial regulation and consumer protection. Dems have been playing defense for the last two years and haven’t really had a chance to figure out an affirmative agenda. Indeed, the abortive Biden/Harris 2024 presidential campaign also stunted the development of a policy agenda. The usual course of things is that a policy agenda, or at least a first 100-day plan, gets hashed out as part of a presidential campaign. I don’t think anything like that got worked out in the Harris 2024 campaign. That means that there’s not a recent playbook sitting on the shelf.
    Now Dems might not bother with legislation–instead, we might just see a constant flow of oversight hearings. Personally, I think that would be a huge mistake: outside of the DC echo chamber, no one really cares a fig about most oversight hearings. It’s not how you build up bona fides with voters and show them that you care about the issues they care about. Being able to point to a track record of legislation that targets key issues like affordability–and has actual observable impacts–is more likely to resonate.
    Given the veto issue, Dems can move two types of legislation. First, they can move legislation that they think the President might actually sign. And second, they can move legislation that they know will be vetoed in order to get the political benefit of a veto. Unfortunately, it’s really hard to know how the President will respond to any particular substantive policy proposal in an area in which he has no real interest, like financial regulation or consumer protection. Nevertheless, there are some topics in the financial regulatory and consumer protection space that might find some modicum of bipartisan support.  Here’s some possibilities:

    (more…)

  • Stablecoins’ UCC Article 12 Dilemma

    Posted by

    The Binance hack has me wondering about the interaction of UCC article 12 rule and stablecoins. The centerpiece of UCC article 12 is a take-free rule, which says that a qualified purchaser (good faith, for value, without knowledge) takes free of competing claims to a controllable electronic record. That take-free rule is hard to reconcile with the ability of stablecoin issuers to blacklist and destroy stolen stablecoins. The ability of the issuer to blacklist/destroy seems like a competing claim to the controllable electronic record. UCC 12 seems to say that a qualified purchaser shouldn’t be subject to having their stablecoin destroyed by an issuer, so if an issuer were to do so, the qualified purchaser would have a conversion claim against the stablecoin issuer.

    To wit, if I received a bunch of stolen USDC without knowing it was stolen, I could be a qualified purchaser. Why should I be deprived of what I paid for innocently and fairly just because someone upstream allegedly engaged in theft? The whole point of UCC Article 12 is to protect me so that I do not have to research if the crypto was stolen. 
    (more…)

  • Careful What You Wish For

    Posted by

    Parts of the financial services industry have sought to clip the CFPB’s wings or even eliminate it entirely since its creation. And as things stand, they’ve basically rendered it ineffective, although of its authorities remain intact. Instead, its lost much of its human capital and its funding stream has been reduced.

    But careful what you wish for. We live in a federal system, and federalism has a hydraulic nature—when the federal channel gets blocked, the current flows down through the states and even local government. And that’s exactly what’s going on. We’re seeing state and local (NYC) government being much more active not just on the litigation front, but also on the regulation front, and state and local governments in blue states face neither the political constraints of federal regulators nor the same statutory limitations. Instead, they are much more likely to express an unchained version of the progressive vision for consumer financial regulation than the CFPB ever did. (more…)

  • How Does Mandating Human Customer Service Help Consumers?

    Posted by

    NYC is proposing a rule that would regulate the use of customer service chatbots. The rule effectively requires either flawless chatbots or the use of human customer service agents. 

    I understand the impulse behind the rule—chatbot doom loops are annoying—but I’m not sure that it’s a problem that needs a regulatory intervention:  there’s no obvious market failure.

    What’s worse, the rule is likely to result in higher costs for all Americans (not just NYC consumers) without achieving any better consumer outcomes. Instead, of a chatbot doom loop, it will just be hours of waiting on the phone for customer service, with no guaranty a more favorable resolution of the issue. NYC is simply mandating an expensive set of rarely-used process rights that have no clear substantive benefit for consumers. In other words, consumers lose in the end here. (more…)

  • The OCC Debanking Report

    Posted by

    The OCC has now released its report on “debanking.” The OCC was unable to identify a single instance in which an individual’s account was closed on account of the individual’s political or religious beliefs. In other words, the report failed to deliver any evidence of the core claim in the Executive Order on debanking that “individuals, their businesses, and their families have been subjected to debanking on the basis of their political affiliations, religious beliefs, or lawful business activities.”

    Instead, the OCC report contains numerous examples of businesses—but never individuals—whose accounts were closed or were denied services because of the nature of the business or hate speech. In other words, the story here isn’t one of persecution of political and religious beliefs. It’s a story of the shunning of hate groups and of banks responding to concerns about the risks posed by particular industries. That’s something really different. 

    Unfortunately, a non-expert reader of the report would think that the OCC had uncovered some terribly damning, nefarious activity. Yet a closer read of the report suggests that the findings are not very significant: the entire debanking narrative is a tempest in a teapot and conflates some rather nuanced issues into a rallying cry for grievance politics. 

    (more…)

  • Levitin’s Financial Restructuring: 4th Edition

    Posted by

    The fourth edition of my Financial Restructuring book is now in print!

    If you’re looking to teach a restructuring course or Chapter 11 class, this is the book for you. The book was the first law school textbook to have substantial coverage of out-of-court restructuring transactions; out-of-court restructuring is the in the book’s DNA, going back to the first edition in 2015. This edition has a lot of expanded coverage of LMEs and Texas Two-Steps, both in the the readings and the problem sets. Numerous students have told me how well they feel these materials prepared them for elite restructuring practices.

    The book (for faculty) comes complete with an extensive teacher’s manual and slide decks and other supporting materials. Available at quality retailers, like Amazon.com. Available for Spring 2027 classes. Get yours while supplies last. 😊

  • Rethinking Corporate Bankruptcy History with Professor Stephen Lubben

    Posted by

    A day-long discussion inspired by former Credit Slips author Stephen Lubben‘s remarkable book, To Protect Their Interests, is a great reason to get yourself to Seton Hall Law School in Newark, New Jersey on October 23, 2026. Stephen has very contemporary takeaways from these carefully documented stories of big corporate bankruptcy development. Register to attend this Seton Hall Law Review Symposium in person here.  If you can’t be there, consider this writing a prompt to get the book and find out whose interests Lubben is talking about.

  • A Kennedy Center Receivership?

    Posted by

    Like many Washingtonians, I’m distraught about what’s happened to the Kennedy Center. It’s the cultural heart of the District, and it’s being destroyed by gross mismanagement that threatens not only the Kennedy Center itself, but also the incredible National Symphony Orchestra (with the Washington National Opera already having cut ties). But maybe there’s a solution: a receivership. (more…)

  • Randy Picker – An Inspiration

    Posted by

    Randy Picker died on August 15, 2026. Randy will forever be a University of Chicago legend, a three-time alum, beloved professor, and, this summer, named to one of the most challenging roles a modern university offers: Vice Provost for Academic Affairs. Randy has been an academic superstar in multiple doctrinal fields, including competition policy/antitrust and intellectual property, as well as in methodologies such as game theory. This Credit Slips tribute emphasizes his contributions to the fields of bankruptcy and commercial law.

    I met Randy in the 1990s as Congress expanded and intensified its aspirations for bankruptcy reform, and got to watch him testify before Congress several times on behalf of the National Bankruptcy Conference. Randy had been the reporter for the National Bankruptcy Conference’s exhaustive review of the Bankruptcy Code published in 1994 and again in 1997 – a monumental undertaking on many metrics, and one that has influenced policy discussions in the intervening decades. By the time I met him, Randy was well-recognized for his bankruptcy scholarship, including co-authoring one of the best known articles on municipal bankruptcy. At a March 1999 House Judiciary Committee hearing, he was given a tough assignment: to explain why a securitization provision in the bill, touted as a no-brainer by its advocates, was problematic. Here is an excerpt of his testimony at the March 1999 hearing:

    The problem is that with regard to securitizations, understanding when you have a true sale and when you don’t turns out to be really hard…. The statute has taken what I would regard as what I think of as a deemed-tiger approach to solving this problem, and what I mean by that is as follows: I think of my 5-year-old son, Adam, walking into the room with his pink stuffed elephant and saying, here’s my tiger. I assume that would get some quizzical looks, right? We’d all look at Adam and say, you know, that’s an elephant, not a tiger. He would say, no, I’ve deemed it to be a tiger, and because I’ve deemed it to be a tiger, it’s therefore a tiger. Well, that’s exactly what this legislation does. If you look at the approach to a definition of transfer on page 286 of H.R. 833, and in particular line 10, a debtor who represents and warrants that a sale is a sale makes it a sale. All you have to do is say it’s a sale. You represent and warrant it’s a sale and you’re done. Well we have never in the history of commercial transactions law relied on the characterization of the parties to the transaction to determine what that transaction is, when it will have third party consequences. Do understand that asset securitization will have third party consequences.

    (Find his full verbal and written testimony starting on page 355).

    Even as other fields and projects consumed more of his time and attention, Randy continued service to the field of bankruptcy, including recently as Vice-Chair of the National Bankruptcy Conference.

    Randy’s commitment to and appreciation of state commercial law also has a long pedigree.  He served as a Uniform Law Commissioner (then called the National Conference of Uniform Law Commissioners, or NCCUSL) at a pivotal time, when Article 9 of the Uniform Commercial Code was being significantly overhauled. He wrote pathbreaking scholarship about secured credit that should inspire more such work now. Throughout his academic career, Randy continued to teach secured transactions with enthusiasm and rave reviews, to the benefit of students and the legal profession.

    Speaking of courses, Randy lived the truth that passion about teaching and scholarly inquiry are mutually reinforcing rather than in opposition. Indeed, Randy was a pedagogical trailblazer. Did I even know what a MOOC was before overhearing Randy mention starting one? When COVID shutdown necessitated remote learning, he created more opportunities for learning and engagement, including taking Zoom’s potential to whole other levels with a remarkable summer seminar for alumni. And he contributed to the education of business school students as well as his law school teaching.

    One last point: Randy was generous with people with no connection with the University of Chicago, with no particular aptitude for game theory or computer simulations (or improv, for that matter). I am such a person. Both early in my career and later, I sought his counsel on academic and professional things. He made time for me and was always constructive. That invisible professional service – whether it reflects kindness or social welfare maximization – is worth discussing out loud, and paying forward.

    Deepest condolences to Randy Picker’s family. He will remain an inspiration.

     

     

     

  • OCC Interchange Preemption Rule

    Posted by

    I submitted a comment letter to the Office of the Comptroller of the Currency regarding its proposed rule on interchange fees as non-interest fees and charges and its preemption order thereunder regarding the Illinois Interchange Prohibition Act.

    My comment letter does not address the policy wisdom of the Illinois law. Rather, it focuses on the legal infirmities of the OCC rule. If we take the Major Questions Doctrine and the Unitary Executive Theory seriously, it is hard to see the authority for the OCC rule for national banks. (Yes, laugh away—we all know that these doctrines only apply in one direction, but let’s at least call out the hypocrisy.)

    For Federal savings associations, the authority is even thinner; the OCC claims in a footnote that they have comparable powers, but the sole authority it cites subjects the Federal savings associations’ power to transfer funds to “applicable law,” which would be both the Illinois statute and federal antitrust laws, such that Federal savings associations cannot receive interchange fees that violate either the Illinois statute or federal antitrust laws.